Mandating BIM At Northwestern Memorial Hospital

December 13, 2013
| Reprints
NMH mandates that clash detection be used for both design coordination and subcontractor coordination. This is an example of typical hard clashes found in a BIM model. Credit: Shrimant Jaruhar/Northwestern Memorial Hospital (NMH)
Click To View Gallery

Northwestern Memorial Hospital (NMH) is an 894-bed academic medical center that’s part of Northwestern Medicine, with a 117-bed community hospital in Lake Forest, Ill., and more than 25 urban and suburban outpatient clinical sites in and around Chicago. Combined, it has more than 5 million square feet of managed space and serves as the primary clinical affiliate of Northwestern University’s Feinberg School of Medicine.

At any time, Northwestern Medicine has a mix of renovation and new construction projects underway.

The teams working on these projects are often challenged during design and construction, due to limited communication between members. In addition, the operators of these buildings are handed over incomplete information on the building upon completion and are unable to use the building data that did exist during the project for ongoing facility management.

To address these challenges, three years ago, NMH released an enterprise mandate to use building information modeling (BIM) for all projects going forward. The first project that was required to meet the mandate was the Outpatient Care Pavilion (OCP). The OCP is a 1-million-square-foot, 25-story building located in the hospital’s downtown Chicago campus. It includes eight floors of parking; six floors of imaging, outpatient surgery, and institutes; and five floors of physicians’ clinics. It’s slated to open in fall 2014.


Start with a plan
To enable successful use of BIM, a BIM addendum was added to the contracts with the architect and the construction manager for the OCP. One of the main ideas behind this addendum is that it requires the project team to collaboratively create a project-specific BIM execution plan (BEP). The BEP sets out the steering and control mechanisms for the BIM process.

The different uses of the model were detailed along with modeling responsibilities and deliverables, and key expectations to allow for a more integrated project process are detailed, too.

Because expectations are set early and clearly, the BEP is an ideal document to monitor BIM compliance. The following are some of the metrics that help track the cost and schedule savings:

  • Number of conflicts/clashes found and resolved prior to construction
  • Number of requests for information (RFI)
  • RFI response and resolution time
  • Budget variance from schematic design to guaranteed maximum price
  • Schedule variance from estimate to actual.

With the BEP in place, the OCP project turned into a laboratory for optimizing BIM processes on all future projects.


BIM for design communication
Before the BIM initiative, communication between ownership and the design and construction teams was conducted primarily through 2-D documents, with limited integration of the team. Owing to its visualization capabilities, BIM allows coordination problems to be known earlier in the project process and then helps the team to develop an informed solution because of a better understanding of the coordination problem.

Communication challenges existed with staff, as well. While department and area managers were invited to take part in planning meetings, it’s challenging to get physicians and nurses into a room to join the end user discussion. A solution was found on the OCP project by placing the BIM model on an iPad with preset views that could be easily accessed.

Combining the visualization and information aspects of BIM with mobile technology allows the clinical, facilities, and support services staff to review their future space when they’re able, rather than waiting for the project team to find a meeting time that suits everyone.


BIM for owner-driven clash detection
NMH mandates that clash detection be used for both design coordination and subcontractor coordination, with guidelines that require certain types of clash tests to be run on a particular schedule that’s determined by the phase and complexity of the project.

of 2Next